689-259-2722
689-259-2722
Window shutters aren’t just decorative—they’re functional, influential in your home’s energy efficiency, curb appeal, and even resale value. Whether you’re renovating or building from scratch, choosing between wood and PVC shutters is more than a design decision. It’s a lifestyle choice that affects how much time, money, and care you’ll invest in your home over the years.
As a homeowner who’s been through the process, I know how easy it is to get swept up in finishes and forget about durability or long-term costs. That’s why I’ve put together this comprehensive, experience-backed guide to help you compare PVC shutters vs. wood shutters across all the factors that truly matter.
Wood shutters are the classics of window design. They’re traditionally crafted from hardwoods like basswood, cedar, or poplar, each offering its own grain and tone. These shutters have been favored for centuries due to their natural beauty, strength, and timeless appeal.
When installed and maintained properly, wood shutters bring warmth and authenticity that’s difficult to replicate. The tactile quality of real wood grain, especially when stained rather than painted, gives your space an organic richness. They work beautifully with traditional or colonial-style homes, and high-end hardwoods can increase property value.
However, wood requires attention. If not regularly refinished or sealed, wood shutters can fade, crack, or warp, especially in areas with high humidity or direct sunlight exposure. I’ve seen wood shutters splinter from impact or absorb moisture and cause frame rot if not properly treated.
PVC (Polyvinyl Chloride) shutters are engineered for performance and minimal maintenance. Unlike wood, PVC is a non-porous, moisture-resistant material that doesn’t swell, warp, or rot. It’s especially useful in wet environments like bathrooms, kitchens, or coastal homes.
Modern PVC shutters have come a long way from their plastic-like predecessors. The latest versions offer realistic wood-like finishes, UV-stable colors, and clean, factory-finished surfaces that stay sleek for decades. They come in a wide palette of colors, and some even feature faux wood grain patterns that rival the real thing.
I chose PVC shutters for a coastal property due to the climate—between salty air, heavy rains, and intense sun, the durability of PVC made it a no-brainer. They’ve held up beautifully, without fading or warping, and cleaning them is as simple as a quick wipe-down.
Here’s where PVC pulls ahead by miles. These shutters resist warping, cracking, rot, and termites. They’re impervious to moisture, making them ideal for bathrooms, kitchens, and any home near the ocean.
Wood, although strong when new, can deteriorate without frequent care. Impact can cause splintering, and unless you stay on top of repainting or sealing, termites and moisture will find a way in. I’ve seen beautiful wood shutters deteriorate fast when left untreated, especially in humid climates.
Meanwhile, my PVC shutters have handled storms, salt spray, and heavy winds without a single issue. Their structure remains solid, and they continue to fit perfectly in the frames without swelling or contracting seasonally.
Let’s be real: real wood has a charm that’s hard to beat. The grain, the texture, the feel of it under your fingertips—there’s a reason wood shutters remain a go-to for interior designers. When freshly stained or painted, wood adds unmatched warmth and elegance.
However, there’s a downside. Wood scratches easily, fades over time, and those rich finishes require ongoing care to maintain. If you’re someone who doesn’t mind sanding and refinishing regularly, it can be worth it.
On the other hand, PVC offers a clean, polished look with minimal upkeep. And the options are no longer limited—today’s faux wood finishes are nearly indistinguishable from the real thing. I loved the color options and consistency of finish PVC provided. There was no worrying about paint chipping or discoloration.
PVC shines in every weather condition. Because it’s non-porous and fully waterproof, it seals tightly and keeps moisture out of the wall cavity. That’s a game changer in wet or variable climates. I’ve seen firsthand how wooden panels, being naturally porous, can trap dust and even wick water into the surrounding frame—leading to costly repairs.
In cold climates, wood may contract and form gaps. In tropical or humid areas, it can absorb moisture and expand, affecting the shutter’s fit and finish. PVC, by contrast, remains stable and intact across temperature swings.
PVC shutters generally cost 10–30% less upfront than high-quality wood options. That savings increases dramatically over time, considering that PVC requires no repainting, sealing, or pest control.
Sure, premium hardwood shutters may boost your home’s aesthetic or appraisal value. But they also come with higher installation fees and ongoing maintenance costs. In my case, I weighed the long-term costs and found that PVC provided more value per dollar—less maintenance, fewer repairs, and consistent appearance year after year.
Maintenance was a major deciding factor for me. PVC shutters can be cleaned with just mild soap and a soft cloth. They never need sanding, staining, or touch-up paint.
Wood, on the other hand, demands your time. Expect to sand, re-stain or repaint, and apply pest treatments every few years—especially in high-moisture or high-sunlight areas. Over the years, those tasks added up not only in cost but also in time spent.
Here’s where things get nuanced. Wood is renewable when harvested from certified forests, but it still involves tree removal and often long transport chains. Processing wood into shutters requires more energy, and if not managed responsibly, contributes to deforestation.
PVC, traditionally considered less eco-friendly, has evolved. Modern PVC formulations use recyclable polymers and lower energy inputs in manufacturing. Plus, their extended lifespan (decades without replacement) reduces waste. In terms of sustainability over time, PVC has a smaller carbon footprint in many cases.
If you prioritize longevity, minimal upkeep, and resistance to weather or moisture, PVC shutters are the clear winner. They offer design flexibility, lower maintenance, and cost savings over time.
However, if you love the authenticity of natural wood, are willing to invest in upkeep, and your climate allows it, wood shutters remain a beautiful, timeless choice. Just be prepared to care for them like you would a fine piece of furniture.
For anyone like me who values peace of mind, clean aesthetics, and strong performance across the board, PVC shutters make the decision easy. I went with Sherwood’s Aeratis PVC shutters for their reinforced louvers and UV-stable colors, and they’ve delivered decades of trouble-free service.
Both wood and PVC shutters have their place. It ultimately comes down to your home’s environment, your willingness to maintain your shutters, and the look you want to achieve.
But if you’re like most modern homeowners—busy, practical, and looking for low-maintenance solutions that still look amazing—PVC shutters are likely the best choice. They’re durable, weatherproof, cost-effective, and available in designs that match any aesthetic.
So before making your final decision, take a moment to weigh what matters most: your time, your climate, your design goals. Then choose the shutters that will serve your home—and your lifestyle—for years to come.
